Where is Hillary Clinton? (Updated x2)
Since Obama’s coronation and McCain’s bold selection of Governor Sarah Palin as his VP choice we’ve seen worse and more blatant misogynism than ever thrown at Clinton during the primary. Obama’s cult following, nutroots gangs, and media have savaged Palin and her family with derogatory, sexist, and vicious rants that have no place in any public or private conversation, much less as part of the political election debate. Throughout this orgy of hate, not one word from Clinton. Not once did she voice protest or urge calm. She sat this out.
Now I support Clinton and did so, respectfully, during the primaries. I suffered derogatory and racist rants from the nutroots gangs, received the hate mail, and endured attacks on my blogs just like every other Clinton supporter. I ended the campaign set to pick up Clinton’s banner again after November and especially in 2012. As previously promised, I have now put my support behind McCain. No to Obama is no to Obama.
I’ve got to be very honest and say today that I am very troubled by Clinton’s out-of-sight inaction on the Democratic attacks against Governor Palin.
Make no mistake, these are Democratic attacks. I realize that Clinton wants to be the party loyalist but is she not an American first?
Weren’t her words and actions throughout her career and during the campaign real? That she hasn’t directly spoken out reflects poorly on her and her legacy. I increasingly wonder if everything she said was, like Obama, ‘just words”? Politics are rough and tumble but there are limits, there are words and actions that are inappropriate. Clinton should know first hand how hateful and how damaging the hate is. Yet, she says nothing, does nothing. Obama has only spoken on the matter once.
If Clinton does not say anything, if she continues to ignore the hate and thereby provide her acceptance and blessing to what Obama and his cult, nutroots gangs, and media following have and are doing, then she will lose my respect. I cannot support and respect someone who will not stand tall on simple matters of right and wrong. The hate spewed by Democrats is wrong and Clinton should know this. To not only sit this out, but to go out campaigning for the candidate most responsible for it is equally wrong.
This is Clinton’s 3 a.m. moment in politics and as a political leader. What she does or does not do will forever mark her.
Update, September 7, 2008, My above post was published in NoQuarterUSA, a follow-on post, below, was published Monday morning:
I wrote a serious post yesterday asking where Clinton was (See Where is Clinton?). This was not to criticize her but to challenge that she is now faced with her 3 a.m. call and how she responds will mark her legacy and also determine her future role in the party and as an elected leader. As SJ writes, “a lot of us will be waiting and watching.” Even though the original post is now stale in our 24×7 Internet age, the matter is far from resolved and Clinton’s moment to respond remains very open, needed, and timely.
Political Correctness (PC) neutered everyone such that Obama and his followers could run amok. People in the Democratic Party were conditioned to avoid saying or doing anything that might offend someone. Hopefully that is a lesson learned. The Republicans learned it well watching Clinton get savaged in the primaries. When Obama tried to then play the race card on them they shoved it back in his face and now no one talks about race anymore.
Republicans are shaming Democrats on sexism and Obama’s misogynism. The party, at least Obama, his cult following, nutroots gangs, and adoring media are being painted for what they are racists, sexist, and hate-filled people. Unfortunately, this poison will last beyond Obama’s defeat in the November.
Clinton has faced and fought against the party’s establishment and the hate-filled people supporting Obama. She lost the nomination, in large part to their hate. She too often played nice, played polite, and played party loyalist rather than calling hate, whether racist or sexist, for what it is — wrong and unacceptable. As her supporters we’ve been far more willing to challenge this hate and say no. We own our votes. We’ve now walked from the party’s nominee and with a wide range of emotions will vote for the Republican ticket of McCain and Palin this fall, ignoring Obama and Biden, wishing and working for their defeat.
Back to my earlier post. This is Clinton’s 3 a.m. moment vis-à-vis the Democratic Party: go along to get along or say ‘No, this is wrong and I want no part of it.’ In my post I suggested that Clinton cannot retain her legacy and have a future in the party by becoming a partner in Obama’s campaign. She’s in a lose-lose position wherein she’ll be blamed for Obama’s loss whether she helps him or not. Should he win, he’ll ignore her and toss her aside. As Dean, Brazile, and others have stated, they don’t need whites, women, latinos, blue collar workers, small town residents, people of religion, and others in their new party — if they win, this is confirmed and Clinton might as well either retire or start a new party.
The responses to my original post now number 700 and range from agreement to shock and anger that the topic was even being raised. Take a moment to read through them. Note, importantly, as you do that it was and is a civil discussion, shared emotion, experience, concern, and hope. The few nutroots gang or off-thread comments were politely addressed. The community at NoQuarterUSA is not Daily Kos, TPM, or other places where any inconvenient question is met with hateful and foul-mouthed response, nor where differences of opinion are not welcomed.
The responses can be organized into several views and proposed courses for Clinton to follow:
- Should she be a nice girl and keep her mouth shut and campaign for Obama and/or down ticket candidates? (That might work for expediency but there is there future upside to this course, whether Obama wins or loses. Importantly, if she says nothing of the hate, does this mean it is okay to use hate against another party but not within the party?)
- Should she punt and say that this is not her fight? The party rejected her and she’ll just sit out the campaign, thank you. (Just take a break for a few months. Return after the vote in November to help rebuild the defeated party.)
- Should she fill the moral and leadership vacuum and say no, this campaign of hate has gone on far too long, enough-is-enough, I want no part of it? (My preferred choice as leadership requires grownup action, whatever the cost. Right and wrong are important judgments that are not a matters of expediency and convenience.)
- Don’t talk about it as all we do is feed the critics.
This is Clinton’s 3 a.m. moment. It is not a question of McCain or Palin (and it pained me to see some of the nutroots trash about Palin repeated in the thread). It is simply a question of what is best for the Democratic Party and Clinton.
What are your thoughts on this?
Update 2, as I’ve just commented at NoQuarterUSA:
I am now listening to Hillary Clinton speak in Florida. As a long-time, original supporter from the early 90s, I’ve got to say I am extremely disappointed to hear her speak unconstrained words of praise and support for Obama. So she has opted to be brow beaten by Obama and still come out and say, he’s a great person, our only choice. I’m sorry, I own my vote and I refuse to forgive or forget.
This is a sad day…

